This story is going to be a super exaggerated version of real events. It is based on my two stepsisters who I renamed, the older one Emily and the younger on Jessica. I’ll rename myself Mark as well, sitting between the two of them in age. I was busted at least once by both of them irl but this is just going to be turning up those events to the extreme.
All characters are 18+
Our parents had gotten married a few years ago. My dad to their mom, Emily and Jessica, each of them was a pain in their own way. Emily as slightly older than me and was at the age where she thought she was better and smarter than everyone. She was the moody one, not the most popular girl at school but she had a healthy group of friends she’d leave the house to hang out with at any opportunity.
Jessica was another deal, being slightly younger she was annoying, trying to pester and get attention however she could. But more than anything she was competitive, all she ever cared about was winning in any way she could whenever she could.
But the worst part, they were both so hot, again, in their own ways. Emily was about 5 foot 8 and had long straight brown hair, a beauty mark above her lip and strong legs from running track, she always wore dark clothes, jeans and boots with dark makeup and lipstick.
Jessica was different, she was shorter, around 5’5. She had a naturally big ass and soft thighs. Her hair was a lighter shade of brown and was usually kept in a ponytail paired with her thick black rimmed glasses. Unlike her sister she had no interest in make up, lipstick or nail polish of any kind.
The other good news was that our busy business parents were extremely absent from the house, leaving me plenty of unsupervised time with them. Even when they were around calls and video meetings kept them locked in their rooms or upstairs office.
My favorite part of the house was the basement, we had a tv, video game consoles, a sofa and bed down there and the parents rarely ever came down.
I had been infatuated with the idea of one of the girls beating me in some kind of simulated fight. That would be hard to organize, I was on average terms with both of them and proposing the idea would be alarming in a way I didn’t want.
However I had an idea, a long shot that I wasn’t sure would work, but it wouldn’t hurt to try either. Jessica was also a big time gamer and the two of us would often be found in the basement playing.
Around the time there was a game the both of us were into, I won’t say what it is but feel free to guess. There was a playable female character in said game who would often, but randomly, strike enemies in games in the nuts. One of the first things that made me realize I’d want to see how that felt.
So I waited until Friday and somehow everything lined up. I went down to the basement and there she was, Jessica, playing the exact game I was hoping she would be, no one else around to witness anything.
I sat down next to Jessica, watching her tear through enemies with ease. “This game is ridiculous.” I baited.
”Who cares? It’s fucking awesome.” She shot back, not responding the way I’d hoped she would.
”It’s just ridiculous, a girl couldn’t, you know.”
”Oh what?” She rolled her eyes. “Couldn’t beat up a guy? You’re so stupid.”
I saw her competitive nature unable to resist, I decides to press more aggressively. ”Yeah, it’s… stupid.”
She barely paid me any attention, continuing to dismantle her in game opponents. “I could neat you up. Easy.”
There it was. “No you couldn’t.”
She paused the game having just cleared her group of enemies, standing up and crossing her arms. “Really? You want to bet?”
”Um, look, I don’t want to hurt you.” I answered, not wanting to seem too overeager.
She laughed mockingly. “Yeah, get up, unless you’re a pussy.”
I stood up and faced her, this was even easier than I thought it would be. She stood before me, barefoot in a pair of grey sweat pants the kind that has elastic straps by the ankles. Along with a black tank top and her ever present glasses.
”Alright. I’ll let you take the first shot.” I offered, hoping to bait her into going for it.
I saw the look on her face, her eyes looked up the ceiling as she thought it over. “What can I do?”
”Anything.” I answered, way too quickly.
”Anything?” She shot back, unsuccessfully concealing a devious smirk.
“Yeah, anything.“ There was no way, she going to do it right off the bat.
”Alright. Let’s do it.” She said.
I closed my eyes and prepared for the impact, i couldn’t believe it was happening so easily, so quickly. The excitement was quickly killed by a voice coming down the stairs.
”What are you two doing?” Emily asked, her boots thudding against every step. Emily did not have patience for nonsense and it wouldn’t be out of character for her to shut us down.
”I’m about to beat up, Mark.” Jessica answered while Emily walked over to the corner bed to lay down.
”Why?” She asked annoyed.
“She’s not going to, she can’t.” I answered, hoping she would disengage.
”Yeah and he‘s giving me a free shot. So we’ll see.” Jessica laughed.
Emily immediately sat up. “No. You guys are fucking idiots, I am NOT spending my night in the hospital because you broke his stupid nose. I’m getting mom and dad.”
“Oh quit being so dramatic, I won’t break his nose.” Jessica laughed.
Emily just laid back down and went onto her phone. “Fine. But if you have to go to the hospital don’t involve me.”
”Yeah we won’t.” Jessica answered then turned back to me.
This was it, I could see it in her eyes she was going for a big shot. I closed my eyes and braced, but nothing could have prepared me. Even though deep down I knew what she was planning there was a part of me that suspected she was going to go for something else. A kick to the knee, or a blow to the stomach or face.
I didn’t actually believe I’d be receiving my first kick to the balls. Nothing could have prepared me, to this day I still don’t know if it was all her strength, her barefoot slammed up into the crotch of my pants. I felt my right testicle take the brunt of the impact, trying to slip away from her soft skin and keep itself from popping.
The decision to fall to the ground wasn‘t even conscious, it was like my body just shut down and forced me to fall into a begging position. Knees on the ground, legs tucked as I was fully hunched over at her feet, inches away from the very body part that just dropped me.
I let out a quiet groan, still loud enough to draw Emily’s attention. “What the fuck did you do to him?” She asked, voice steeped in her anger and annoyance.
”You’re so smart. Take a guess.” Jessica taunted.
”You kicked him in the balls?” She said in disbelief. “Don’t fucking do that, you’re so weird!”
”What?! He told me I could do anything. You should have seen it.” Jessica laughed.
Emily stood up and held up her arms “I don’t want to see my little sister kick my stepbrothers balls.”
Jessica laughed “It was really funny.”
”Jesus, you’re so fucking weird, Jessica.” Emily shot back.
During the course of the conversation I found time to recover, slowly getting to my feet. I was completely weak, standing up was all I could do and even that was taking everything.
What I really wasn’t expecting, was another kick from Jessica’s bare foot, slamming into the exact same place, once again pulverizing the right one.
I had dropped to the ground again before Jessica even laughed or Emily responded.
”Ok I’ve had enough.” Emily said as she went for the stairs. “You guys have fun.”
”Are you gonna tell mom and dad?” Jessica asks.
”No. I’m not telling mom and fucking dad.”
”Can you bring me some ice?” I asked meekly.
Emily doesn’t even answer as she marches up the stairs. “Ew. Ew. Ew. Ew. Ew. Do not make me think about your fucking balls.”
I stayed huddled in defeat as Jessica stood over me. I felt her gently pat the back of my head.
”I’ll get the ice for your nuts.”